On Saturday night I was watching the CBC's coverage of the police action at Queen and Spadina when I realized I had the rare chance to head to a movie. A call to the Scotiabank theatre didn't say anything about a G20 closure so I zipped down to Richmond and John, where I discovered the theatre was closed. Drat. On my way back I checked out what was happening at Queen and Spadina.
My arrival happened around 9 p.m., a couple hours after the police car was torched. Riot police cut off Queen on the intersection's east side. This seemed relatively reasonable—the torched police car was just east of there. Then for no discernible reason the line of police pushed into the intersection. They stopped traffic both ways along Spadina. And they antagonized the crowd of about 150 people. The line of riot police took various shapes. It was a diagonal slash across the intersection. It was a series of dots. And then it reconvened in a thicker mass on the west side of Queen, cutting north-south from the McDonald's to the T-D bank and compressing a loose mass of people into a tight crowd on Queen West.
I walked through that crowd. Maybe a handful of them were protesting something. Of the actual protesters, the majority seemed to be against violence in protests. With rage, on the verge of violence, one woman kept shouting, "Peaceful protest!" A few of them were people like me, people who had seen the thing on the television and were fascinated by the spectacle near our homes. I bumped into a teacher from Myron and Penny's Montessori school. She was riding around the city on her bicycle and had taken some remarkable photographs. Her roommate was filming the police action with her cellphone.
And then the rest of them were kids, local guys and girls, many of them just out of high school and doing their best impersonation of the black bloc members they'd seen on the Internet. Many of these people were indignant about the police action's infringement of their civil liberties. Toward the line’s north end the police were cutting off pedestrian traffic and to do this they had to push forward a few of the folks there. One of them got indignant about it. "Fuck you!" the kid screamed into the shield. "Fuck you!" shouted back the cop. The profanity excited the crowd. "I told you there'd be some fun tonight," one kid crowed to his buddy.
Now little skirmishes were happening up and down the line. Now helicopters thrummed above. Now word of this disturbance was being tweeted and status-updated. Within the universe of the G20 disobedience, Queen and Spadina existed now like a flypaper, a honeypot attracting those buzzing around town, looking for action. And with each second more balaclavas and hoodies arrived.
I thought about the rhetorical spiral that preceded the G20—the anarchist rumours, and the chest-beating conducted by the police in response, and the way the media chattered and chirped every confrontational vow. Would that our society could act with more maturity. But both sides seemed to be spoiling for a fight. The kids at the line were 21-year-old boys with too much testosterone, and the police were acting like 21-year-old boys with too much testosterone. And now at Queen and Spadina I saw the way the police action perpetuated itself, the way each coordinated action of these black-clad shock troops provoked something similar from the civilian side. I wondered whether the police were contributing to the chaos—whether, if the police dispersed, the crowd would have, too. But no, the police couldn’t. The rhetoric from the previous week had ramped up to the point that conflict wasn’t just inevitable—it was necessary.
There was one guy in the centre of Queen who shouted a little more loudly, a little closer to the cops. He turned his back on them for a second and three of the police rushed forward, snatched him, and sucked him back, past the line, presumably to be zip-tied and processed and dispatched to the temporary jail over on Eastern Ave. Now the civilian side grew more indignant. They had no right, they muttered to themselves. Something had to be done. Some members of the crowd began creeping toward the police. For the first time, I wondered about my own safety.
And then from far off I heard a familiar sound, a sound I initially dismissed as my own imagination, a sound I’d been hearing for weeks over the television but I thought was impossible now. Wasn’t it? How could someone have one all the way over here? Soon it grew hard to ignore, and seconds later I saw the guy creating it—a normal-looking kid, maybe 18, in standard-issue shorts and a T-shirt and blowing with pursed lips, he was even with me, now he was past me, he went right up to the cop line and with all his might blew into the deafening plastic bugle known as the South African vuvuzela. The cops just looked at him, stone-faced as he kept it up. Meanwhile, many in the crowd were smiling. The vuvuzela's arrival worked to ease some of the tension. It seemed a perfect symbol for the hubbub at Queen and Spadina. This wasn’t a demonstration. This didn’t have anything to do with global politics. As were other things that attracted the bellow of the World Cup's plastic bugle, this was an activity for boys of a certain age. This was a spectacle. This was sport—one, I realized as I turned and headed for home, that didn’t interest me.
---
Above pic is from BlogTO's photostream. And if you're in the mood for another alternative look at the G20 protest, check out Craig Silverman's story about Steve Paikin's Tweet-reports from a similar disturbance. Plus here's an illuminating clip from the scene on Sunday at Queen and Spadina, where my sister's boyfriend was caught in the cordon and spent four hours zip-tied in the rain. And here's another great compilation of street-level coverage from Torontoist.

